The Ministry of Science and Technology (MoST) in Pakistan is on the verge of a major overhaul as the federal government aims to streamline its departments by eliminating inefficiencies. The restructuring comes after a subcommittee, part of a higher-powered right-sizing committee, recommended the closure or merger of several underperforming entities within the MoST. If implemented, these changes could reshape the ministry’s future and how science and technology initiatives are managed in Pakistan.
The Subcommittee’s Recommendations: Closing and Merging Key Departments
In an effort to enhance efficiency, the subcommittee has recommended that the Pakistan Council for Science and Technology (PCST) and the Council for Works and Housing Research (CWHR) be shut down entirely. These entities have been labeled as low-performing, with little to no justification for their continued existence. Additionally, the Pakistan Council for Renewable Energy Technologies (PCRET) has been earmarked for a merger with another institution, the specifics of which remain undetermined.
One of the most significant changes proposed involves the transfer of universities currently operating under MoST’s supervision to the Ministry of Education. This would significantly reduce the Ministry of Science and Technology’s portfolio and shift the focus of these academic institutions toward educational, rather than technological, objectives.
The suggestions put forward by the subcommittee are part of a broader strategy to right-size the federal government, and if approved by the right-sizing committee, these recommendations will be forwarded to the federal cabinet for a final decision. This means that the fate of institutions like the PCST, CWHR, and PCRET hangs in the balance as their future depends on the cabinet’s approval.
Concerns Overlapping Functions and Revenue Deficits
The subcommittee’s scrutiny extended beyond just performance metrics. They also highlighted redundancies within the ministry’s structure. For example, they noted that the Pakistan Halal Authority (PHA), established in 2016 under MoST, has overlapping functions with other departments like the Pakistan Standard and Quality Control Authority (PSQCA) and the Pakistan Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (PCSIR). The suggestion was made to merge PHA with PSQCA and transfer its control to the Cabinet Division.
This streamlining move raises concerns over the role of these entities and whether such consolidation would reduce inefficiencies or compromise their specialized mandates. For example, the PHA plays a pivotal role in certifying Halal standards, which is a crucial component of Pakistan’s export markets, particularly in food industries. A merger may dilute the PHA’s specific expertise.
Additionally, the subcommittee raised alarms over the poor financial performance of PCSIR. Despite receiving billions of rupees annually from the government, the council has reportedly failed to generate sufficient revenue to justify its expenses. The rationale behind continuing to fund a loss-making entity has been questioned, and this may lead to a significant downsizing or restructuring of PCSIR’s activities.
A Leadership Crisis Looms Over MoST
Another glaring issue affecting MoST’s performance is the leadership vacuum within its various departments. Nine critical departments under MoST, including PSQCA, PCRET, the National Metrology Institute of Pakistan (NMIP), Pakistan Science Foundation (PSF), National Institute of Electronics (NIE), National Institute of Oceanography (NIO), COMSATS University, and the Pakistan National Accreditation Council (PNAC), currently operate without permanent heads. This leadership crisis has severely hampered the functioning and productivity of these departments, according to ministry sources.
The reliance on ad hoc management has meant that these organizations have struggled to meet their objectives or contribute significantly to national development in science and technology. Research and development, a cornerstone of technological advancement, has particularly suffered, with innovation stalling in many sectors.
Without robust leadership and strategic direction, MoST’s entities have failed to produce tangible results or generate revenue, which in turn has made them prime candidates for closure or merger. Many ministry officials have expressed concerns that the proposed changes, if implemented, could lead to the ultimate dissolution of MoST itself, as key functions and departments are transferred to other ministries or shut down altogether.
Broader Implications for Pakistan’s Scientific Landscape
The proposed overhaul is part of a broader government effort to right-size federal departments, aiming to make them more efficient and less reliant on public funds. However, the ripple effects of these changes could be significant for Pakistan’s scientific and technological landscape.
MoST has historically been responsible for spearheading scientific research, technological advancement, and the promotion of innovation in the country. The potential closure or merger of key departments raises questions about the future of science and technology initiatives in Pakistan. Will these functions be absorbed effectively by other ministries, or will the move lead to a scaling back of vital scientific research and development?
For example, the potential merger of PCRET, an entity focused on renewable energy technologies, could have implications for Pakistan’s efforts to combat climate change and shift towards sustainable energy solutions. The dissolution of entities like the PCST and CWHR could leave gaps in critical areas of research and technological progress that are necessary for the country’s long-term development.
The Future of MoST: Reshaping or Dissolution?
As the recommendations move forward to the federal cabinet for approval, MoST stands at a crossroads. The final decisions made by the government will determine whether the ministry remains a central player in Pakistan’s scientific future or whether its responsibilities are significantly reduced or transferred to other departments.
Many insiders at MoST are concerned that the right-sizing efforts are not addressing the core issues affecting performance, such as the leadership crisis, lack of resources, and strategic direction. Instead, they fear that the focus on mergers and closures could erode the ministry’s capacity to foster innovation and support Pakistan’s long-term technological ambitions.
At a time when nations around the world are increasing their investments in science and technology to stay competitive, Pakistan risks falling behind if it does not carefully manage this transition. MoST’s fate will serve as a bellwether for the government’s broader approach to scientific and technological development in the country.
Comments